City takes a shot at sidewalk bicyclists, but it’s mostly legal sorry, no it’s not.
Looks like I got this one wrong; see bold below.
Not that I want to be talking about bikes on sidewalks forever, but . . .
Yesterday, CP's Tom Dreisbach reported that the City Planning Commission voted to raise the penalty for riding a bike on the sidewalk from $10 to $50.
The vote is intended, presumably, as a nod to the many people annoyed by bicyclists on sidewalks. Certainly we've heard that sentiment here since my article on Philly as a Biketopia came out.
Sidewalk biking can be annoying, especially in Center City, and while it is illegal in some cases (more on that in a sec), I wonder if some of the outright hostility directed against people who ride on the sidewalk isn't misguided. My guess is that most people who ride on the sidewalk – inexperienced riders in particular – are simply scared of traffic, and with plenty of good reason.
Maybe the best way to do that is to make the streets safer and more inviting to cautious riders – as well as enforce current laws, such as they are.
But, meanwhile, it turns out that most sidewalk riding is actually legal. It's only in "business districts" that it isn't according to Pennsylvania law; Tom Dreisbach, however, points out that a city ordinance specifically forbids biking on sidealks anywhere by anyone over 12.
The Pennsylvania Bicycle Laws say the following:
Section 3508. Pedalcycles on sidewalks and pedalcycle paths.
(a) Right-of-way to pedestrians.-- A person riding a pedalcycle upon a sidewalk or pedalcycle
path used by pedestrians shall yield the right-of-way to any pedestrian and shall give an audible
signal before overtaking and passing a pedestrian.(b) Business districts.-- A person shall not ride a pedalcycle upon a sidewalk in a business
district unless permitted by official traffic-control devices, nor when a usable pedalcycle-only lane
has been provided adjacent to the sidewalk.
But, Philadelphia Code states that:
(1) No person shall ride a bicycle upon a sidewalk within a business district, as such district is defined in The Vehicle Code.
(2) No person 12 years of age or more shall ride a bicycle upon any sidewalk in any district.
(3) Whenever any person is riding a bicycle upon a sidewalk, such person shall yield the right-of-way to any pedestrian and shall give audible signal before overtaking and passing such pedestrian.
(4) In areas under the jurisdiction of the Fairmount Park Commission, riding bicycles on sidewalks and foot paths may be permitted when authorized by regulations of the commission.[7]
Thanks for the correction, Tom.















How about we start fining the jaywalkers in Center City that I almost kill every morning?
Coming up 7th st b/t Walnut & Arch is like School Kid/Business Folk Frogger!! And it’s not like 7th st. isn’t already lined with cops parked in illegal parking spots…
Okay now that they’ve raised the fine for bicyclists how about raising, or enforcing, some of the blantant motor vehicle violations; running red lights, gridlocking, double parking. I see more of those violations than cycle violations. That’s more revenue for the city for enforcing existing laws.
Park an officer at 22nd and Lombard in the mornings and ticket the cars parked in the bike lanes. There’s usually one getting donuts with a car parked in the bike lane anyway.
That would be great Erin. We should start waterboarding bikers who almost kill pedestrians also. I wrote a brief that makes that actually legal.
Thanks to Mr. Thompson for the reference to Pa. Vehicle Code (Title 75):
Center City is a business district, therefore bicycle riding on sidewalks is therefore illegal. That should be enough but The Philadelphia Code reaffirms it.
§12-808. Riding on Sidewalks:
(1) No person shall ride a bicycle upon a sidewalk within a business district, as such district is defined in The Vehicle Code.
(2) No person 12 years of age or more shall ride a bicycle upon any sidewalk in any district.
(3) Whenever any person is riding a bicycle upon a sidewalk, such person shall yield the right-of-way to any pedestrian and shall give audible signal before overtaking and passing such pedestrian.”
This an excerpt of the University of Pennsylvania’s policy:
“B. Synopsis of Pennsylvania and Philadelphia law
1. Human powered, pedal cycles are vehicles according to the Pennsylvania Vehicle Code.
2. Vehicles, as indicated in #1 above are subject to the provisions of the vehicle code when operated on the highways and may not stop, stand or park where prohibited or where controlled by official traffic control devices to include firelanes, handicapped zones, etc.
3. The Philadelphia Code prohibits any person above the age of 12 from riding a bicycle on any sidewalk or pedestrian pathway in a business district. The Penn Campus area meets the definition of a business district.”
Conclusion: It appears that the City of Philadelphia agrees with the State of Pennsylvania. Center City is a Business District and therefore bicycle riding on sidewalks by anyone over 12 years of age is illegal.
Just at Broad & Chestnut the police could ticket at least 20 bikers per hour. Let’s see: $50 per ticket on an 8 hour shift means $8,000 per day and $2.9 million per year. From just one intersection! No need to close libraries or pools.
I was too busy getting my facts straight and posted them without seeing your correction.
But at least we all know what the law really says.
I am a sidewalk biker, and this fine increase if anything has raised my desire to ride on the sidewalk. I will be out tomorrow, full-speeding down a sidewalk near you, so get the fuck out of my way. And if you are trying to “fine” me you’ve gotta
catch me first!
When they catch you, SB, not only will the waterboard be waiting but we’ll put electric clamps on your nipples.
Enjoy tomorrow, superstar rebel.
All very clever comments but can anyone weigh in on the application of this stuff for when I get gripped up by an old city cop.
Doesn’t the state law trump the local? Doesn’t that mean that I can argue from B of the state code, if there is no bike lane and I yield (get off my bike) to pedestrians, I can resort to the sidewalk?
Seems a reasonable compromise between Isaiah and the hard liners who pounced on this.
This bicycle on the road thing is all fine and dandy. Only problem being, most motorists don’t know bicyclist are supposed to use the road. I can’t tell you how many times motorists have yelled at me to “GET THE FU*K OFF THE ROAD!”
I believe it is unfair to force citizens into a known hazardous/hostile situation. The City of Philadelphia has a responsibility to properly inform all citizens of the rules of the road. More “share the road signs” and PSA’s are critical to ensuring safe motoring, biking and walking!
Hey all – I’d like to point back to a post I put up a couple of days ago in which I referenced a study (not a great one, albeit) that indicated that biker behavior seems to be less erratic when bike lanes are present on a street.
http://www.citypaper.net/blogs/clog/2009/06/09/bike-lanes-in-center-city-philadelphia/
There’s some debate within the biking community as to whether bike lanes are really the answer, but I’m starting to lean towards thinking they are important.
Thing is, it’s a tiny minority of people (us) who argue about the fine points of biking and the law; most people, I think, just sort of do what they think makes the most sense. Bike lanes, even though they’re just paint, do seem to give both drivers and bikers a sense of order that’s currently lacking. Drivers can see the lanes and realize they are obligated to share the road; bikers can see them and realize they’re better off not just biking all over the place.
It seems to me that part of what makes big bike cities like Amsterdam work is, more than anything else, the *expectation* of bikes and cars interacting in a certain way. Hopefully, as biking continues to increase in Philly, that will happen anyway, but maybe lanes will help.
Thanks for all your comments.
Pedestrians also need to learn the rules of the road. Crossing against the light without looking will get you hit. It’s nice that all the responsibleity is on bikers to keep everyone else safe.
Instead of all these various fines and such, it would be AWESOME if the city did a major re-education campaign about how bikes, walkers and drivers should co-exist.
I think the idea that drivers will ever accept bicyclists in the street is a dream. It’ll never happen, even if we become more inclusionary with messaging, signage and bike lanes.
I ride a bike, and I only ride in the street at night or during non-traffic-heavy hours. I’m fortunate that my ride in to work is a route of wide sidewalks with almost no pedestrians. But, as a bicyclist, my objectives are to a) get where I’m going and b) do it safely. The second that the latter is compromised while riding in the street, I will take to the sidewalk and stay there.
Also, drivers are mean and yell mean things.
I don’t have a point. Just sharing my experience.
I always ride in the street, except when I am pulling up to dismount and lock up my bike.
Drivers yell mean things, honk unnecessarily and crowd me out of my (far-right lane) position regularly.
This is biking in the city. We need more bike lanes that cross town (the idea of making Spruce and Pine one lane and adding a bike lane would be perfect) and drivers need to be aware of cyclists.
Riding on the sidewalk is very frightening to pedestrians. If you are too scared to ride a bike like a vehicle, in the road, perhaps you should practice in the wide bike laned streets before making a daily bicycle commute.
The issues are enforcement and education. Until the police are onboard to enforce this law, all of this discussion/venting is for naught. Bikers will continue to do what they have done for years, which is the reason I will continue to keep on hating them. I love it when I see police do nothing while these behaviors happen right in front of them, when I read another City Paper article quoting,of all people,a bike shop owner saying he chooses to ride on sidewalks(is that what he tells his customers?),when some of these posters say in essence “screw you” I’m still riding on sidewalks. With respect to Center City, there is no better motivator than for the Phila. Police to be given a share of the revenue raised by enforcement. This would cover all ticketable offenses like running red lights,stop signs etc. Get the jaywalkers too,they are just as bad. Get the motorists for not sharing the road with bikers - the right lane of Chestnut Street is supposed to be off limits to everything except bikes and busses, but is it enforced? There is a plan to put rookie police on foot patrols. Why not incentivize them to enforce by means of a bonus system, a “bike count” of sorts. Write tickets,raise money! The Parking Authority has taken this to a level which is the envy of other cities and the detriment of street parkers, but revenue is being raised, just where it goes is another matter. I would bet if the police were properly motivated to enforce this and other traffic laws, word would spread among you bikers and behaviors would change. In regards to education or should I say ignorance: The Bicycle Coalition wants to “suggest” staying off sidewalks as if they are afraid to offend bikers with something more direct, I hope the Bicycle Ambassadors affect change. The author of this article smugly put it out there until corrected later, that it really is legal to ride on sidewalks. Do bike shop owners educate their customers? What about in Chinatown where it seems everyone is on a bike on a sidewalk, does the Chinese community there educate it’s own? Do they even know the laws? Same applies to the Mexican community in the Italian Market area. I have been told Mexican immigrants here refuse to ride on the streets because they are run over in Mexico. Are restaurant owners educating their bike deliverymen? On and on. Nothing happens overnight. But at the end of the day, you and I and more importantly, our grandmothers, should be able to walk the sidewalks in peace in this City without an uneducated or just plain jackass bicyclist weaving around us and using the lame excuse that “the big bad cars made me do it”. Other cities have the balls to do this, why can’t we?
[...] writer ponders how to make the city a cyclist’s paradise, and says riding on the sidewalk is mostly not legal. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)City Hall remains in pursuit of coolness as [...]
Ray- You come off like a DORK and a RACIST. “mexican community in the Italian market area?” Dude… get a clue. I also really enjoyed your “incentive” idea for ticket-writing POLICE… in a city where citizens and police alike are being gunned down at an alarming rate, it’s nice to see you’ve got your big dorky racist brain working overtime on how to make Philly nicer.
Loser.
I agree with Felicia’s post above. If you’re afraid to ride in the street, stick to the playground or the Schuylkill Rive path.
That said, don’t expect me to ride into traffic in order to get out of your way if you’re riding your bike the wrong way up 21st Street. It’s your decision to ride against traffic, so live (or die) with it.
@ Ray Cist
Uhhhhh . . . so there isn’t a Mexican community in the Italian Market? Because I’m pretty sure there’s a huge one. What’s your point? How is it racist to discuss the existence of a community? He wasn’t saying Mexicans ride on the side walk SO THAT MEANS THEY ARE A RACE OF BAD BAD PEOPLE, he was simply discussing what goes on and the reasons behind it. Chill the fuck out. You sound like a dork for attacking a stranger on the internet over something really stupid.
Ray: Take a breather on this. I get it, we all get it - you hate bikes on sidewalks, nobody more than me. Not to worry, I have cut the chains from a few bikes whose operators acted like the skateboarders they really are and I will keep doing it. Taking the high ground does not work, you misjudged your audience. You tried to be politically correct and look where it got you, you’re called a racist. Not me, I don’t care. There are Hispanics, Mexicans, Cambodians, Chinese, you name it, tooling around on bikes doing whatever the hell they please. Let’s call them “those who don’t speak English”. Educate them, ticket them, spoon-feed them. I don’t give a shit but tell them how we do things in this country.
Ray Cist: get the “cist” out of your eyes and open them, there are Mexicans all over Washington Ave. They must also live north of Chinatown because every morning they come south like the Mongol Hordes on sidewalks. Why is that? They are probably undocumented, read: ILLEGAL, and the bike is the easiest way to get around. I guess that makes me a racist. What shootings are you talking about in Center City, where this could work? Of course this won’t happen in Kensington or North Philly. Any bike cops I ever do see look like the urban equivalent of life guards: always taking to women or each other.
Ray: you’re diatribes are correct but this is not the place for them. Remember, CityPaper and PW support sexual slavery by accepting advertisements from asian massage parlors with half-naked pictures of women, so that children can see them, in their honor boxes. TRY AND REFUTE THAT EDITORS, I DARE YOU! You take advertising money from brothel owners who make their girls pay off a debt to get here from Korea. This makes you as hypocritical as the people, any Republican, you go out of your way to “expose” on a weekly basis. Give me a break!
Yoo lovey sexslave smokeyjoe long time.
OK YOO. Judging from that name maybe you own a few of the brothels along Race and 13th street., the ones that prey on conventioneers and that CityPaper shamelessly takes ads from. You only post shit because you are a piece of shit.
Aah-soh, smokeyjoe. You come in visit again, hypocrite.
Ray.. next time youre cutting the chain off of someone’s bike (which is a total lie I bet) I hope one of these illegal undocumented mexicans you’re so angry with comes up AND SLITS YOUR FUCKING THROAT!
A couple of comments — it is nice to know that there is a law forbidding cycling on the sidewalk. I’ve been sidewalk-riding (as necessary) when a bike lane is crowded with cars, or the sidewalk is free of pedestrians, or street construction forces me onto the sidewalk. Now, I should watch out. I still don’t see what is so wrong with riding on the sidewalks as long as you use good bike etiquette and announce your presence (so not to sneak up on an unsuspecting pedestrian ambling along while on a cell phone). I am all for cyclists announcing “on your left…on your right, etc.). I do think people appreciate that - besides sharing the sidewalk or road is so much nicer than the antagonism and anger. Finally, since City Council voted 17-0 (reported on June 16 on Philly.com) to ban handheld cell phones while driving, doesn’t it seem that fair that unapologetic and incorrigible drivers who continue to drive and chat should also be penalized (as cyclists are going to be fined). I thought I read that Mayor Nutter signed the cell phone ban but I have not observed any decrease in cell phone use by drivers. Even as a pedestrian, I’ve nearly been driven over (several times) while a driver drifts through a crosswalk while trying to finish up their call or text message.
Having been run down by one cyclist speeding through a red light, nearly run down by several others who were not obeying traffic laws, and harassed by numerous cyclists ON THE SIDEWALK, I am quite happy that the city is making even small moves to do something about this menace.
Wanna ride a bike — then DO IT IN THE STREET and OBEY THE TRAFFIC LAWS.
If you’re too afraid to ride in traffic, then the answer is simple: DON’T RIDE A BIKE.
I used to ride a bike. Once I became too freaked by traffic, I sold the bike and now either walk or take public transit. I don’t drive a car.
I cannot support cyclists in any issue as long as any of them continue to ride on the sidewalk or break traffic laws when they do decide to ride in the street.
We all have to cooperate for things to work. Just because you ride a bike doesn’t make you immune to laws or to public courtesy when encountering pedestrians.
What’s awesome is: we bikers own this city’s streets, and can navigate from A to B quicker than any of you crybaby whining “anti bike” dumb asses. We will ALWAYS be out, in your face and sharing your streets, sidewalks and anything else that’s rideable here in the beautiful, free U S of A. If you can move with common sense, chances are you won’t get hit. But if youre a moron on your cell phone holding a giant fucking coffee than you’re just as likely to get creamed by SEPTA as smoked by the friendly mexican delivery guy. Just be happy that every biker you see running a red light or jumping a curb is one less moron in a car polluting your air and running yellow-to-red lights.
Don’t hate cuz YOU CAN’T HANG on your bike anymore… geezer!
What happens when gasoline reaches $2.00 a liter? I think it’ll happen in 2010, June I believe.
Automobiles break as many laws as biker do, running reds, double parking, turning against the light, no signals, only they do so with much more danger. Getting hit by a car running a red light is much different than getting hit by a bicyclist. Everyone should be able to see the difference. I’m unsure of why pedestrians are afraid of bikes. Bikes are the most unstable thing you can ride. Bump them and they go over. I walk and ride bike and have little patience for anyone, no matter their mode of transportation, who blatantly thumbs their nose at laws required to keep everyone safe. As it should be for anyone but to single bicyclist out as the sole cause for all commuting hazards is ridiculous.
When does the new fine go into effect? I read all these posts weeks ago and thought it all a bunch of hot air until I started to notice just how bikers do all of these things. In Center City over the long weekend I counted how many bikes were on sidewalks and blatantly ran a redlight, it was something like 90% of bikers I saw. The close calls I noticed between a car and a bike; it was the bikers fault for trying to cut off the car. There are way too many bikes on sidewalks swerving around pedestrians, someone will be hit. While I was in NYC recently I saw their cops enforce their laws against this crap, there are foor patrols everywhere. Philly needs foot patrols and/or more bike patrols. You bikers aren’t helpng your cause when most of you act this way.
City Council passed the bill (Bill # 090444) on June 11, and Mayor Nutter signed the bill into law on June 24. The bill’s provisions have already gone into effect.
It remains to be seen if that means the PPD will actively pursue people who bike on the sidewalk. After all, the the fine has existed for years, albeit at a reduced rate, and anecdotal evidence points to close to zero enforcement during that time.
Have any of you Clog readers seen someone get fined for biking on the sidewalk?
- Tom Dreisbach
I’d like to have ticketed the cop car parked illegally in the bike lane in front of the 7-11 this morning. The cop was standing inside browsing the magazines.
The issue of bicycles and scooters coexisting with cars and pedestrians on city streets is a complex issue, requiring a much broader approach than the enforcement of one law. I’m no expert, but in recent discussions with some very knowledgeable people on this subject, I’ve been able to get a broader understanding of the challenges we face in trying to become a 21st century city. Just a few things to consider, for example. A growing number of young families are moving into neighborhoods on the periphery of center city, and biking into town on a daily basis. Seems to me, the more we can do to encourage young creative people to stay in the city, the better off we’ll be as a city. If they can do so without the expense of owning a car, even better.
Having said that, we do not yet have the infrastructure in place to support a Bike Share program, for example, which would give all citizens unlimited access to bikes. But, I believe we will have that infrastructure in place before too long. It makes too much sense, and there are too many people who believe in the vision of a true bike-friendly city, to believe otherwise.
Our biggest challenge, I’m told, is that we live in a city which has mostly narrow streets. A wonderful thing for pedestrians, and general quality of life. But challenging for planners wrestling with transportation issues.
An increase in bike lanes, which would negate the need to use sidewalks, would necessitate additional parking alternatives, as the number of parking spaces would decrease in the city. So, parking alternatives are tied to the solution.
There is also the question of where to store/park bikes and scooters in the city. So, shared parking lots for bikes and cars might be part of the solution, too.
i could go on and on, but what I’m trying to point out is that this is a complex issue, but imminently solvable. It will require innovative solutions borrowed from other cities, and other countries. It will require a communication plan that, over time, breaks down the vitriolic attitudes on both sides of this issue, and recognizes that if we’re going to move forward as a city, we’re going to have to do it together. Bikes, scooters, cars, pedestrians… all. It’s going to require new approaches to traffic patterns, shared resources, and law enforcement.
It will require public discussions, civic engagement, political pressure, and some small steps to begin to change the city in ways that invite alternative transportation options that move people efficiently, effectively, and with less stress.
Why we start imaging what’s possible and go form there?
To HIKI: I’ll bet if you said something to the cop he/she would have moved the car or at least thought about it next time. The cops don’t know/don’t care about bike lanes, sidewalks, pedestrians, etc. They aren’t made to think about it by their district commanders, they have “real crimes” to address - could be. There are too many of them in cars in Center City and they are usually on a cell phone! They need to be on foot to change their point- of-view. They need to visit NYC to see how it’s done. I feel safer in mid-town Manhattan than here at City Hall. I see cops there everywhere. The only time I see a real police presence in Philly is during times like the Flower Show to make the suburbanites feel safe in the “Big City”, and yet I still see bikers on sidewalks riding right through the cops at 12th & Arch. Any change like this comes from the top, fill out a PPD Roll Call complaint.
it should be mandatory for every aggressive driver to ride a bike through the city
In response to Tom Dreisbach’s question: I saw two bike cops last week riding on the sidewalk at 15th & Walnut, and asked them if the new $50 fine for sidewalk riding is being enforced? Their response: they didn’t know of the new fine and they don’t enforce the law against riding on sidewalks anyway! The cops don’t care. The bike cops in that part of town are usually parked at Rittenhouse Square talking to girls while bikers whiz past them on the sidewalks. It’s like watching lifeguards.
Asked another cop, this time in car T12 at the Wawa at 11th & Arch this morning, about the $50 fine: She says don’t pay any attention to it because she isn’t doing anything about it. What a great City!!!
Hey, are drivers in Jersey reading this?
it is a GREAT city… cops do real work, while we bikers get to whiz around the city- thru red lights, and on sidewalks- completely unchecked! it’s grrrreat!
join us ray, I mean smitty, or keep whining on the bike threads…you suck!! hahahah.