MUSIC . Aid or Invade

Native American

Rodney Anonymous vs. the World

Published: Mar 11, 2008


(CLICK IMAGE FOR LARGER VERSION)

Artists: Various

Album: Prophecy 2 (A Hearts of Space Native American Collection)

Country of Origin: Native American

Remarkably gifted author Sherman Alexie once said that the greatest threat to the American Indian is middle class white women who are obsessed with "Native Spirituality." So, while it's tempting to remind oneself while listening to Prophecy 2 (Valley Entertainment) that this CD is most likely to be purchased in a New Age bookstore, along with a "spirit-catcher," by the Desperate Housewives of Orange County, it's important to remember that you should never judge a genre of music by the people who consume it: Otherwise, jazz would be irrelevant just because most jazz enthusiasts are exactly as they were portrayed by Steve Buscemi in Ghost World, and not for the simple reason that all jazz music is lame.

ADVERTISEMENT

Unfortunately, after a promising little intro, Prophecy 2 — not to be confused with the film Prophecy II, which Christopher Walken, Jennifer Beals, Brittany Murphy and Eric Roberts all wisely dropped from their résumés — turns out to be exactly what we feared it would be: a New-Agey mishmash of chants and native flute layered atop wispy synth pads, cheesy guitar licks, bird chirps and honky-tonk piano. With the exception of Johnny Whitehorse's "Iron Horse" and Mary Youngblood's "Silent Wolf," this entire CD is about as enjoyable as having your teeth cleaned by a blind dentist. I defy any of you to go through the entirety of the liner notes (which helpfully inform us about the return of Pahana, the "lost White Brother from the stars") without screaming in pain.

Great Spirit-fuckin'-dammit, this CD makes me want to kill white people! Isn't it bad enough that we pushed the American Indians to the edges of their own lands — and engaged in 500 years of the sort of genocidal behavior that makes Ghengis Khan look like Chaka Khan — without having to shove their music between two slices of white bread and selling back to them as a shit sandwich?

Verdict:

Invade your local New Age bookstore and demand that they knock this crap the fuck off, right now. "Lost White Brother from the stars" my ass.

(r_anonymous@citypaper.net)

Free rain sticks at rodneyanonymous.com.

 

Comments

with a mouth like your i would say that you need to safegaurd your self from yourself.

anyone who sees the way of living in balance with the land is mimicking native american spirituality?

you must live in a big city and only walk in beauty in your imagination to say such things.

i dont care about what you have to say about a CD, you can have your opinon, go back to your apartment and watch nature on televion.
by ken on March 12th 2008 5:43 PM

Hiya Ken,

Since I WROTE that column instead of passing it along orally to the other members of the Wiseass Nation, it's not my mouth but my Editor, Chief Red Pen, whom I need to safeguard myself from.

My anger is with what I see as the cheapening of Native American culture (and with the STARZ channel for pulling their dirty movies from the ON Demand menu). Most people who see "the way of living in balance with the land" are not mimicking Native American spirituality: unless, of course, they have blonde hair, blue eyes, have changed their name form Sheila Henderson to "Squatting Cloud", and have given away their trust funds to a "Medicine Man" who looks remarkably like Jimmy Kimmel. Oh and in my imagination, I'm walking through Amsterdam.

Thanks for the suggestion that I watch "nature" on the TV in my apartment (please see my complaint about STARZ, above); however I currently reside in a large, lavishly furnished house with Ms. Keira Knightley.

Thanks and keep writing,

Rodney "Running Duck" Anonymous

PS. "Lost White Brother from the stars" my ass.
by Rodney Anonymous on March 13th 2008 6:41 PM

You fuckin' tell 'em, Rodney!!!
by Dave on March 13th 2008 10:44 PM

More liberal spew about how white people destroyed Native American life and committed genocide.

Go turn on Starz and jack off to Hyapatia Lee.
by Garth on March 14th 2008 7:39 AM

Anyone who doesn't believe their culture is being cheapened is either in denial or responsible for cheapening it. Its been happening for centuries! Chinese made dream catchers,Hollywood movies and albums such as these prove my point! White people dillute every culture they come into contact with by profiting off of things that don't accurately represent other cultures beliefs(although I think they left Islam alone for obvious reasons). Just look at the "Buddha" statuettes you see at the mall(which are mainly Shinto gods NOT Buddha).
by jake on March 14th 2008 9:31 AM

Pvt. Joe Bowers: What ARE these electrolytes? Do you even know?

Secretary of State: They're... what they use to make Brawndo!

Pvt. Joe Bowers: But WHY do they use them to make Brawndo?

Secretary of Defense: [raises hand after a pause] Because Brawndo's got electrolytes.
by Rodney Anonymous on March 14th 2008 6:13 PM

i guess thats part of our culture?.. cheapening/destroying other cultures by finding ways to market and sell it?.. WELCOME TO AMERICA!. i wonder if this cd is anything like the cd with the monks chanting.. you know, it came out like 10-15 years ago.. with all the timelife commercials.. c'mon, you remember..
by billyclean on March 15th 2008 11:31 AM

Yes we have the right to market off of others but do you honestly believe its right? People also have the right to buy the cd but they shouldnt be fooled into thinking these are authentic Indian chants. The artists on the cd are probably all PART native American and probably live in Big City. If they trully wrote songs representing their people they would write about massacres and being relocated to reservations, but seeing as how it does appeal to white middle aged housewives they basically all write about nature and add some synth.
by jake on March 15th 2008 12:15 PM

There is a blues-rock artist who is full-blooded American Native by the name of Bill Miller (I have NO idea what his Tribe calls him...other than 'Bill', I suppose).
He has the kind of songs that their culture should be PROUD of AND he slips into moments of chants and Native music so authentic that makes one's scalp ache. He's like the 'Boss' of the Native Americans rock-scene and puts on one HELL of a show (I guess he's still touring...I haven't seen him for a while).
My point is that you just have to find the right stuff out there. Big City or pueblo plateaus, if the Spirit is in it, that's all that matters. Just stay away from new age self-help and help yourself.
And don't buy any CDs of Peruvian Pan Flute Bands, either!
by Jeronimo Gray on November 3rd 2008 7:16 PM


All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking Post Comment, you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Name
please enter your name
Email (will not be published)
please enter a valid email
Comment
please enter a comment
Enter the security code on the right in the textbox below.
Security Code
please enter the code
Join the City Paper Mailing List
 

Also In This Week's Music Section

Bow To No One
by Shaun Brady

Yes We Can (Destroy Y-Rock)
by Patrick Rapa

Soundadvice
Music Picks:
Red Heart the Ticker
by John Vettese

Music Picks:
Tift Merritt
by M.J. Fine

Music Picks:
Wolter Wierbos
by Shaun Brady

Music Picks:
Pierre-Laurent Aimard
by Peter Burwasser

Music Picks:
Lizz Wright
by Deesha Dyer

  • Bow To No One
  • Yes We Can (Destroy Y-Rock)
  • Soundadvice
  • Red Heart the Ticker
  • Tift Merritt
  • Wolter Wierbos
  • Pierre-Laurent Aimard
  • Lizz Wright
Recent Comments
Advertisements
 


search restaurants by name
search by neighborhood
Search
search by cuisine
title
theater

Search
search for:
within:   of  
more jobs
(use zip or city, state)
Search
"Great vision without great people is irrelevant."
—Jim Collins, Author,
"Good to Great"
In Partnership with JobCircle
start date / /  select date
end date / /  select date
category
keyword
Search Buy Concert Tickets
Category:
Keywords: Search

Search Real Estate

ALL | MON | TUE | WED | THU | FRI | SAT | SUN

or

LOCATION:

ADVERTISEMENT