May 4-10, 2006
Slant : Feedback
Letters to the EditorGloria E. Davis
Sanford, N.C.
Laddie has recently been hospitalized and is now a resident of Fairview Care Center on Bethlehem Pike. I fear that my brother will burn out there; Lord love him, he wants to be around people he knows on the Hill ... [where] he has some great, loving people that let him know that he is cared for. I am afraid that too many people around Philadelphia are worried about how having a shelter in their area will affect businesses and the worth of their homes. [I hope] Mt. Airy and the Hill can come together and find a way to agree on a homeless shelter. Please, Philadelphia, remember that Laddie is only one of the many deserving souls who need your support.
Mary Sykes
Beaverton, Ore.
I am sorry the ER staff was not helpful and friendly and that you had to wait an excessively long time to be seen, but that is the product of a capitalistic health care system, not McDonald's.
Name Withheld
Standing upright is Shane Coleman, whose story about attempts to recruit him as an undercover informant is presented warts and all. Just across the page is a blurb teeming with eye-catching references to "highly skilled killers" who just moved to Philadelphia from Eastern Europe, but there's not a named source to be found.
If CP and its "law enforcement insiders" think this story is so darned important, find someone who will say so. I expect this kind of dreck from the New York Times Sunday Styles section, not CP. There are legitimate reasons to use anonymous sources. I don't think you came close.
Amanda Bergson-Shilcock
Bryn Mawr
We are concerned, however, that the piece might leave readers with a misleading impression about the supposed lack of diversity at our school, stemming from the sensationalized headline and a pull-out quote from another Girard student alleging that "white alumni don't even send their kids or grandkids to the school, nor do the teachers."
To assume that the racial composition of the school is the reason alumni and faculty don't send their children or grandchildren here indicates a misunderstanding of Girard's mission. We admit children from families that lack financial resources, each headed by a single parent or guardian. Most alumni and faculty members, while they might head single-parent families, generally do not qualify under income guidelines to send their children to Girard.
In fact, some alumni and staff have enrolled their children herewhether they're black or white makes no difference as long as their children pass our admissions tests and requirements, including the household income guidelines. Each of our 720 students in grades 1 through 12 receives a complete scholarship covering tuition, books, uniforms and room and board to attend this unique boarding school.
The article also talks about the racial makeup of our faculty, but does not include the fact that 79 percent of the residential faculty who care for and work with the children in the dormitories are black.
While it is true that there are no current faculty recruiting efforts, the reasons are twofold: We recruit faculty members as the openings arise, generally at the start of the school year, and teacher tenure averages 9 years and 11 months. Of the 11 teachers we have hired since the beginning of the current school year, one is black, one is Hispanic and one is Asian.
Our average starting salary is competitive with that offered by city public schools, but the teachers we attractand more importantly, retainare more concerned about the impact they will make on the lives of youngsters than the money they will make. Our teachers like the small class sizes, attentive students, support of the residential staff and working in a safe, enclosed campus.
Given our tradition and history as a school, and the significance of Girard's 1968 desegregation to Philadelphia's civil rights history, we at Girard College recognize the need to embrace diversity. This is reflected in our recently updated strategic plan, as Jackson noted in his article.
Girard junior Michael Daly's comments at the end of the article would have provided a more constructive pull-out quote: "In the end, people are people. Girard may not be the most diverse place that you'll encounter, but the eclectic group of students and staff make this one of the most unique places I have ever experienced."
Dominic M. Cermele
President, Girard College
Alumnus, Class of 1959
Stephen L. Wakefield
Bedford, Texas
Your comments are insulting to a great American artist. If you do not like his art, go back to reporting on any of the modern mass-produced art that can be created by anyone, even a kindergarten child.
Jeanne Janney
Chattanooga, TN
Of all the forums, this topic seemed to invoke the most controversyfor good reason. Like an addict, a city that can't admit it has a problem obviously can't take steps to fix it. Philadelphia must break its addiction to haphazard planning.
What does smart development look like? For starters, developers should create housing around transportation hubs. Accessible, convenient transit is a key to community vitality and Philadelphia should actively promote development that takes advantage of existing infrastructure. Philadelphia must also remove obstacles to creating more green buildings. The recent struggle to install waterless urinals at the Comcast Tower demonstrates that our city can be a hostile environment to developers who are trying to contribute to the sustainability of the city.
While Schimmel points out the city's failings, he does not recognize the many efforts to change the status quo in Philadelphia. The Urban Sustainability Forum, the Design Advocacy Group and Next Great City are all pushing for more sustainable practices in Philadelphia planning. Instead of focusing on gloom and doom, Philadelphians have lots of chances to push our city government to think smarter about development.
The Philadelphia of the 21st century is within reach. We just need to take the first step toward it.
Christine Knapp
Outreach Coordinator for Eastern PA, PennFuture
Schimmel's comments apply to historic preservation as well as to general planning and environmental issues. The eagerness to encourage development of new housing has led to zoning variances for new development projects in historic districts that create buildings out of scale and out of character with these districts. It is an example of that old phrase "throwing out the baby with the bath water." The historic character of Center City and Philadelphia neighborhoods is what makes Philadelphia great and it's obviously why developers want to build in these historic settings. But the incompatible scale and character of much of this new development is adversely affecting the very historic settings that give them value. We need a new attitude toward development in Philadelphia that balances preservation with growth, as well as encouraging environmentally sustainable design.
John Andrew Gallery
Executive Director, Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia
But most of all it raises the medical ethical question, that surgeons do no harm to healthy tissue. And then brings this into question by suggesting that face lifts and surgery for aesthetic purposes also include the excision of healthy tissue.
To make castration unethical is also to make these procedures unethical. I hope people reading this come to the same conclusion I did: that the Hippocratic imperative to "do no harm" in this case does not necessarily refer directly to the tissue itself, but to the long-term mental health and well-being of the patient. This must surely be the goal of all surgeons.
The only quote that stoked my fire was from Dr. Sherman Leis: "There are a lot of sick, psychotic people out there. ... A legitimate doctor doesn't operate on somebody who is psychotic. That's incompetent medicine."
My suggestion to him would be that to call someone psychotic simply because you cannot empathize with their conditiontheir innermost feelingsis a mind-set of someone unfit to practice medicine. A doctor's primary concern should be for the patient, not a preoccupation with one's own personal views.
If this person also has difficulty relating to transsexuals, or someone who is gay, does that mean that they too (in this person's mind) are "psychotic"? Who will be next for this doctor's judgment, and who placed him in such a high place to judge?
A very grateful eunuch
Via E-mail
A very well-balanced article that covers all sides of the struggle to become a eunuch. This has been the best article in print on the subject. Your work will open the minds of many who before could not understand the drive many of us had to become our true selves.
John Thornton
Newark, Ohio
Love ya and your baked beans!!!
Laura Belle
Via E-mail

