|
|
||||
![]() |
![]() |
|||
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
||
![]() |
||||
![]() |
||||
|
|
April 24-30, 2003 movies Truth Hurts
Steve James talks about turning the camera on himself. "Where does our responsibility to people … end?" asks the manager of a rural Illinois general store in Steve James’ harrowing documentary, Stevie. It’s just about his only line in the movie, but when an otherwise inessential character is kind enough to summarize the theme of your movie, you leave it in. At the center of Stevie is the relationship between James and Stephen Fielding, who was a troubled, desperately shy boy when James served as his Big Brother while attending graduate school in southern Illinois. Ten years later, promises to keep in touch fallen by the wayside, James returns to find that Fielding has grown into a troubled young man who's been in and out of jail several times, still lives with his grandmother, can't hold a steady job and has grown a calloused exterior around his childish shyness. By the time James returns two years later, things have gone from bad to worse: Fielding has been charged with sexually molesting his 8-year-old niece. Trust is, of course, at the very heart of the documentary process: Without it, people would never allow themselves to be filmed (although most reality-show participants don't seem to care how they look as long as they get on TV). With Fielding, though, James was starting from less than zero. He had to convince someone whose trust he'd already betrayed to trust him again. "The issue of trust with this film didn't start out where it ended up," James says from home in Chicago. "When I first suggested to Stevie it might be interesting to do a little film about all the intervening years since I'd lost touch with him, it wasn't going to be a very ambitious film, just a little portrait, looking back on the time I'd been his Big Brother. But then that changed with his arrest." Fielding's arrest also changed his relationship to James, and James' relationship to the film he was making. Although James' other documentaries are essentially in a cinéma vérité vein, where the filmmakers' ultimate goal is to have no effect on the people they're filming, Stevie takes the risky step of bringing James into the frame, essentially making him the part-subject of his own documentary. While his presence in some scenes is minimal, in others James comes to the fore, urging Fielding's lawyer to more aggressively pressure his client to cop a plea, or helping broker a reunion between Fielding and the mother who all but abandoned him. Not one to seek the spotlight, James was reluctant to cross the line. "I never started out with the intention of being in the film," he says. "Part of it was, film or no film, I did get drawn back into that relationship. It became a question, if we're going to proceed, how to account for that. It seemed like [including me] was the only honest way to proceed." James was all too aware of the way his presence in the film might seem contrived or self-aggrandizing. "One of the pitfalls is you really are in a house of mirrors," he explains. "Even if what you're putting in is self-critical, it can appear -- or even be -- a backdoor attempt for sympathy from the audience. It was very important that I had help from the other producers, the other editor, to have those other voices to assess where my character lay within the story, to try and walk that line between being candid and honest and self-critical, but not coming off as a ploy for sympathy." James admits he's broken the vérité creed, but he muses that Stevie is, in some ways, "almost meta-vérité, in its candidness about my own involvement." Indeed, though the movie keeps self-consciousness to a minimum, it addresses issues that are usually the province of experimental film, where the filmmaker's relationship to and effect on the work is incessantly questioned. One issue that cut particularly deep was whether or not nonfiction filmmaking is inherently exploitative, the science of packaging other people's lives for profit. While Fielding was in jail, he and James "talked at length" about whether to continue filming or not, but even securing Fielding's permission, James says, "didn't keep me from feeling that I might be essentially violating a trust. Any documentary where you're following people and misfortune befalls them, that question always looms for the filmmaker, and for sensitive viewers. And this is a film in which those issues were inescapable." James was further sensitized by being a character in his own film, a process that proved surprisingly painful. "Being in front of the camera was a slap in the face of just how exposed one can be," James says. "But this film is, for me, the most honest film I've made, and the most complicated. It really reminded me how important it is to try and present people in as complex a way as you can, while still trying to make a compassionate film. Sometimes those things can be at odds, to be honest and compassionate and complicated." Stevie opens Friday at Ritz Five. See Sam Adams’ review on p. 31.
-- Respond to this article in our Forums -- click to jump there
Recent Comments
Get a Map of Philadelphia Sewn into a Blanket `Hey, perfect for "the city of neighborhoods" I bet West Mt Airy, Fishtown, Gray's Ferry, Powelton Village and Germantown will want their own.` » Local couple arrested for skipping out on tip `Bradley,
There is a basic minimum of service required at a restaurant in which a 15% tip is what is the norm expected. A good server who exceedes expectations ` » Council's problematic bicycle crackdown `Last year I was stopped in an intersection waiting at a red light when i biker on the sidewalk did'nt look in front of himself and by the time I saw him ` » 'Cause flashmobs are awesome: Freeze 'n' read at noon `Pretty good turnout for the "Literacy 'Freeze' You" event. It was more regimented than other flash mobs I've been a part of, with organizers coordinating ` » Medical Tourist `I would like to add my perspective as a medical researcher who has been involved in stem cell studies for the past 5 years. The fact is, the only difference ` » THE GOOD WORD Vol. 13: Collin Flatt of Phoodie `Ah, good to see our Collin in something other than the police blotter. Dude, you really have to stop braising people's pets. That is clearly the thigh ` » Medical Tourist `Dear Profit in Unregulated Clinics. The ICMS is a nonprofit organization. It is not interested in profit. By law, it can't make a profit. What it is interested ` » Medical Tourist `Dear Profit in Unregulated Clinics. The ICMS is a nonprofit organization. It is not interested in profit. By law, it can't make a profit. What it is interested ` » Phila Pols say Foxwoods should get the boot `The writer asks, "why, then, do there seem to be efforts afoot in Harrisburg to help the faltering casino afloat?"
Answer: Because the local investors ` » Check out Meal Ticket's Felicia D in Grub Street's Bartender's Bible
`Major awww moment here. Thanks for the kind words! You guys are the twist in my Manhattan!` »
Web Exclusives
Repertory Film Your weekly guide to local film events, festivals and under-the-radar screenings. Tim Hecker Sat., Nov. 21, 7:30 p.m., $12 with Aidan Baker, Kung Fu Necktie, 1250 N. Front St., 215-291-4919, kungfunecktie.com. Something Good DANCE REVIEW: Fräulein Maria Letters to the Editor What You Say Icepack
Amorosi on the news, nightlife, gossip and bitchiness beats.
Popular Articles
Invasion of the Body Slammers How South Philadelphia became the center of the alt-wrestling universe. The Nutter Special We're not so different from the Iron City. In a Class by Itself THEATER REVIEW: The History Boys No Benefits
Forget the public option — gimme a SEPTA plan. ![]() Academy of Natural Sciences: Family Four-Pack of Tickets | Mango Moon | Prive | Bliss | Raw Dawgs Saloon | Cream and Sugar | S & H Kebab House | Cafe Nola | Copabanana | Hollywood Tans: $50 for $25 HALF OFF DEPOT Why live life at full price? Search Real Estate
Today's Big Deal:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||